[Django]-For all my foreignKeys, should i use User or UserProfile in Django?

by

2πŸ‘

βœ…

I think You should use User. UserProfile should be custom and can differ on each project. So if you will use same code for another project you can probably fail because of that. Also it is always easy to get user object in code and from that you have no problems to get profile user.get_profile() as you show (and profile is not always needed). So ingeneral I think it will be easier to use other modules and passing them just user object (or id) and not the profile.

What is also could be the solution – write your own class which will be responsible for the users. Just write methods to return profile, return stuff_needed or whatever you want and everything just by passing user object and additional parameters about what you want.

So in short, I’m for using User for Foreign keys, because in my opinion it just more logical, while the User model is always the main one (you always have it) and UserProfile is just extension.

Ignas

πŸ‘€Ignas ButΔ—nas

1πŸ‘

If you just want all the goals belonging to a specific user add a foreign key to User in your Goal model.

class Goal(models.Model):
    user = models.ForeignKey(User)

def myview(request):
    goals = Goal.objects.filter(user=request.user)

Or alternately save all the goals for a user on your UserProfile model and do

def myview(request):
    user_profile = user.get_profile()
    goals = user_profile.goals

…or use a method to do processing to calculate them

goals = user_profile.calculate_goals()
πŸ‘€Zach Kelling

0πŸ‘

I’ve been pondering the same thing myself for one of my sites but i decided to use UserProfile rather than User.
Not sure if its the right decision but it just seems more flexible.

πŸ‘€sean2000

Leave a comment